- All orders placed from 12/30/2014 at 9PM (CET) onwards will be billed dated 2015 -
libelium
  • rss
  • flickr
  • instagram
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube

Linux Embedded Devices Comparison: Yun, BeagleBoard, Rascal, Raspi, Cubieboard & pcDuino

Posted on July 1, 2013 by Cooking Hacks There have been 1 comment(s)

Awaiting for the new release, Arduino Yun, I think it's very interesting to know more about the new linux devices in the market. There are a lot of emerging ones and many of them agree in the same feature: to be Arduino-compatible.

Why?

Arduino was launched in 2005 and it has become in a standard as a modular platform, so all new devices want to add this feature, allowing people to use each platform as easy as Arduino.

Some can carry Ethernet, Wifi, HDMI, NAND flash... these features change in each board we are going to compare. But all of them have GPIOs, and even an expansion board to make the port easy.

A quick review of each one

 

Arduino Yun. Arduino Yún is the combination of a classic Arduino Leonardo (based on the Atmega32U4 processor) with a Wifi system-on-a-chip running Linino (a MIPS GNU/Linux based on OpenWRT). It’s based on the ATMega32u4 microcontroller and on the Atheros AR9331, a system on a chip running Linino, a customized version of OpenWRT, the most used Linux distribution for embedded devices. Like a Leonardo, it has 14 digital input/output pins (of which 7 can be used as PWM outputs and 12 as analog inputs), a 16 MHz crystal oscillator and a micro USB connector.
http://blog.arduino.cc/2013/05/18/welcome-arduino-yun-the-first-member-of-a-series-of-wifi-products-combining-arduino-with-linux/

BeagleBoard-xM. BeagleBoard-xM delivers extra ARM ® Cortex TM -A8 MHz now at 1 GHz and extra memory with 512MB of low-power DDR RAM, enabling hobbyists, innovators and engineers to go beyond their current imagination and be inspired by the BeagleBoard.org community. Designed with the community inputs in mind, this open hardware design improves upon the laptop-like performance and expandability, while keeping at hand-held power levels. Direct connectivity is supported by the on-board four-port hub with 10/100 Ethernet, while maintaining a tiny 3.25" × 3.25" footprint.

http://beagleboard.org/hardware-xM

http://www.cooking-hacks.com/index.php/beagleboard-xm.html

BeagleBone A6. BeagleBone is a credit-card-sized Linux computer that connects to the Internet and runs software such as Android 4.0 and Ubuntu. With plenty of I/O and processing power for real-time analysis provided by an AM335x 720MHz ARM® processor, BeagleBone can be complemented with cape plug-in boards to augment functionality.

http://beagleboard.org/Products/BeagleBone

http://www.cooking-hacks.com/index.php/beaglebone.html

Cubieboard. Cubieboard is a small (10x6cm), hacker friendly, extendable and very low-cost while powerful ARM board with Allwinner A10 SoC.

http://cubieboard.org/

http://www.cooking-hacks.com/index.php/cubieboard.html

pcDuino. pcDuino is a mini PC platform that runs PC like OS such as Ubuntu and Android ICS. It outputs screen to HDMI. Moreover, it has hardware headers interface compatible with Arduino.

http://www.pcduino.com/

http://www.cooking-hacks.com/index.php/pcduino-dev-board.html

RascalMicro. The Rascal is a small computer that you can use to monitor and control the world remotely. The Rascal is powerful enough to handle real web traffic, but you don't have to be a professional electrical engineer to use one. The Rascal has its own web-based editor on board, it works with most Arduino shields, and you can program it in Python.

http://rascalmicro.com/

Raspberry Pi. The Raspberry Pi is a credit-card sized computer that plugs into your TV and a keyboard. It’s a capable little PC which can be used for many of the things that your desktop PC does, like spreadsheets, word-processing and games. It also plays high-definition video. We want to see it being used by kids all over the world to learn programming.

http://www.raspberrypi.org

http://www.cooking-hacks.com/index.php/shop/raspberry-pi.html




Which one should I choose?

As I said in my previous post, comparing Arduino Yun and Raspberry Pi, it depends of your final purpose:

miniPC: if you are looking for a portable PC with HDMI connection, there are 4 options in the table: BeagleBoard-xM, Cubieboard, pcDuino and Raspberry Pi, but Raspberry Pi allows to use a RCA output if your TV doesn't support HDMI connection. You can run a Linux distro, but you will need more RAM, depending of the use of your computer. In this case, you can choose between 1Gb (Cubieboard, pcDuino) or 512Mb (Raspberry Pi, BeagleBoard-xM). Regarding to the storage, Cubieboard has 4Gb NAND flash so you can take advantage of this feature instead of using an external storage. BeagleBoard-xM would be the most complete among them, with more I/O connectors for A/V: camera, S-Video, Audio (play, record)... Raspberry Pi and Rascal Micro would be the next but, if the price is one of the most valuable variables, Raspberry Pi would win.

Arduino compatible: if you are looking for a direct Arduino compatible device, there are 5 options. The first one, Arduino Yun. It is the only one with embedded WiFi connection. It has a MIPS-based Wi-Fi SoC running Linino (similar to OpenWRT) so you can control the web server with this device and use it as a common Arduino (with the Digital/Analog I/Os). Rascal Micro and pcDuino have the same Arduino sockets so you will be able to plug any Arduino shield directly. There are some expansion shields or bridges for the other platforms, like the Raspberry Pi to Arduino Shields Connection Bridge. In this case, I'd choose Arduino Yun. Nice device which derives the complex control of WiFi connection through a Linux distro and combines it with the easy programming of the common GPIOs.

Here you can find a comparison between the boards:


Name Arduino Yun BeagleBoard-xM BeagleBone A6 Cubieboard pcDuino Rascal Micro Raspberry Pi Model B
Price $69,00 $201,00 $89,00 $49,00 $60,00 $199,00 $35,00
Processor ATMega32u4 16 MHz ARM Cortex-A8 1 GHz TI AM3359 ARM Cortex-A8 720 MHz Allwinner 1 GHz ARM Cortex-A8 1 GHz ARM Cortex A8 CPU AT91SAM9G20 ARM926EJ/S @ 400 MHz BCM2835 ARM11 700 MHz
Graphics N/A C64x, DSP core LCD Mali-400 OpenGL ES2.0, OpenVG 1.1 Mali 400 core N/A Broadcom VideoCore IV
RAM 2.5KB 512 MB LPDDR 256 MB DDR2 512M/1GB DDR3 @ 480 MHz 1 GB DRAM 64 MB 512 MB
Storage 32 KB flash 4 GB flash (microSD) 4 GB flash (microSD) 4 GB NAND flash 2GB Flash microSD card SD Card
Size 2.7” x 2.1” 3.25” × 3.25” 3.4” × 2.1” 3.94” x 2.4” 4.93” x 2.05” 2” x 4” 3.37” × 2.125”
Input Voltage 5V 5V 5 V 5V 5V 5 V 5 V
Interfaces Digital GPIO 14 RS232, I2Cm I2S, SPI, GPIO GPIO I2C UART SPI CAN I2C, SPI, IR Digital GPIO 14 Digital GPIO 14 GPIO, UART, I²C, SPI
USB 2.0 microUSB, USB Yes (4) Yes Yes (2) microUSB, USB Yes (2) Yes
USB Device USB Host Client, Host Client,Host Host Client,Host USB Host USB Host
Storage Slots microSD microSD MicroSD microSD microSD microSD SD
Ethernet Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Wi-Fi Yes, Atheros AR9331 MIPS-based Wi-Fi SoC running Linino, No No No No No No
Mic In No Yes No No No No No
Audio Out No Yes No Yes No Pins for I2S Yes
Analog In 12 Yes Yes No 12 4 Yes
Analog Out 7 (PWM) Yes 8 (PWM) Yes 6 (PWM) 7 (PWM) Yes
HDMI No DVI-D No Yes Yes No Yes
Other Video Out No Camera, SVIDEO No No No No RCA

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_single-board_computers

David Bordonada
Cooking Hacks Team


This post was posted in Arduino, Comparative, General, News and Events, Raspberry Pi

1 Response to Linux Embedded Devices Comparison: Yun, BeagleBoard, Rascal, Raspi, Cubieboard & pcDuino

  • You should really take a look at the pcduino3. It has a dual core 1GHz A20 processor comes with 1G of ram and 4GB flash. It also comes with wifi and a sata connector on board. The pcDuino3 is works well as a small desktop PC and can also live in the arduino ecosystem i.e. it can run 3.3v arduino uno shields.

    Posted on June 19, 2014 at 4:21 pm

Comments